Hi {{first name | there}},
The right question in weight loss is not “how much?”
It is “from where?”
A pound can come from subcutaneous fat under the skin. It can come from deep visceral fat around the organs. It can come from fat in the liver, water and glycogen, or muscle you very much wanted to keep.
We all know we would rather lose fat than bone or muscle. The less obvious point is that fat loss itself is not uniform.
Subcutaneous fat, visceral fat, liver fat, and intramuscular fat do not carry the same physiology.
That is why this question matters in the GLP-1 era. In the STEP 1 extension, people regained about two-thirds of the weight they had lost within a year of stopping semaglutide. In SURMOUNT-4, people who stopped tirzepatide regained substantial weight, while people who stayed on it maintained or lost more.
That does not mean the drugs are useless. It means obesity often behaves like a chronic condition, and the tissue-level response matters: visceral fat, liver fat, waist, glucose, blood pressure, muscle, and fitness.
This letter is about how exercise, nutrition, sleep apnea care, alcohol reduction, and medication tend to affect visceral fat, liver fat, and muscle, and what I would do to lose the "right" weight as a longevity-informed physician.

